Skip to main content
Leech Tishman: Legal Services
  • Why LT
    • About Us
    • Leadership
    • Life at LT
    • Careers
  • People
  • Capabilities
    • Practice Groups
      • Business Restructuring & Insolvency
        • Business Restructuring & Insolvency Overview
        • Bankruptcy Chapters 7 and 13 Debtor
        • Bankruptcy Chapter 11 Debtor
        • Bankruptcy Chapter 11 Subchapter V Debtor
        • Business Wind Down and Liquidation
        • Court Appointed Trustees and Receivers
        • Creditors’ Rights
        • Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors in Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Proceedings
        • Prosecution and Defense of Avoidance Actions in Bankruptcy
        • Real Estate-Related Insolvency
      • Construction
      • Corporate
        • Corporate Overview
        • Asset Protection
        • Business Succession
        • Capital Markets
        • Commercial Contracts
        • Construction
        • Corporate Compliance & Ethics Program
        • Corporate Governance
        • Data Privacy & Cybersecurity
        • General Counsel
        • Government Relations
        • Investment Advisory
        • Lending
        • Mergers & Acquisitions
        • Nonprofits & Tax-Exempt Organizations
        • Secured Transactions
        • Securities
        • Software Development and Licensing
        • Start-Up Services
        • Tax
        • Women/Minority-Owned Businesses
      • Healthcare
        • Healthcare Overview
        • Healthcare Litigation
        • Healthcare Regulatory Compliance
        • Healthcare Corporate Transactions
        • Healthcare Government Investigations
      • Intellectual Property
        • Intellectual Property Overview
        • Copyright Protection
        • Litigation – Copyright
        • Litigation – Patent
        • Litigation – Trademark
        • Patent Preparation and Prosecution
        • Patent Validity, Infringement and Freedom to Operate Opinions
        • Trade Secret
        • Technology Agreements and Transactions
        • Trademark Clearance, Preparation, Prosecution and Maintenance
      • Labor & Employment
        • Labor & Employment Overview
        • Discrimination, Sexual Harassment and Employment Litigation
        • Employment Policies & Prevention
        • ERISA, Employee Benefits & Executive Compensation
        • Immigration
        • Public Sector Employment
        • Restrictive Covenants / Non-Competes
        • Traditional Labor Law
        • Wage and Hour
        • Workplace Investigations
        • Workplace Privacy
        • Workplace Safety/OSHA
      • Litigation
        • Litigation Overview
        • ADA Title III Defense Litigation
        • Alternative Dispute Resolution
        • Appellate
        • Commercial Litigation
        • Construction Litigation
        • Defamation: Libel, Slander, and Commercial Disparagement
        • E-Discovery
        • Election Law
        • Family Law and Matrimonial Law
        • Government & Internal Investigations
        • Insurance Coverage
        • Trusts & Estates Litigation
        • Product Liability Defense
        • Real Estate Litigation
        • Restrictive Covenants / Non-Competes
        • Shareholder / Equity Disputes
        • White Collar Defense
      • Real Estate
        • Real Estate Overview
        • Assessments and Appeals
        • Development
        • Environmental
        • Franchise Development & Leasing
        • Landlord/Tenant Law
        • Leasing
        • New York Co-Ops and Condominiums (Closing Capabilities)
        • Oil & Gas
        • Permitting and Zoning
        • Real Estate Litigation
        • Real Estate-Related Insolvency
        • Transactional Commercial
        • Transactional Residential
        • Leech Tishman Closings
      • Tax
      • Trusts & Estates
        • Trusts & Estates Overview
        • Asset Protection
        • Basic & Complex Estate Planning
        • Charitable Planning & Giving
        • Federal Estate, Gift, and Fiduciary Taxation and Compliance
        • Florida Homestead Exemption
        • Guardianships
        • Marital Agreements
        • Private Foundations
        • Probate and Orphans’ Court Practice
        • Special Needs Planning
        • State Estate, Inheritance, and Fiduciary Taxation and Compliance
        • Tax
        • Trust & Estate Administration
        • Trusts & Estates Litigation
        • Trust Creation, Modification, and Termination
    • Industries
      • Aviation & Aerospace
      • Beauty & Wellness
      • Cannabis
      • Data Privacy & Cybersecurity
      • Energy & Natural Resources
      • Entertainment & Sports
      • Healthcare
      • Life Sciences
    • International
      • International Overview
      • Asia Practice
      • Europe Practice
      • Latin America Practice
      • Middle East Practice
  • Insights
    • Client Alerts
    • Tariff Tracker
    • Firm News
    • Press
    • Events
    • Success Stories
    • Podcasts
    • Resources
    • Videos
  • Offices
  • Careers
  • Payments
  • Contact
Leech Tishman: Legal Services
  • Careers
  • Payments
  • Contact
  • Why LT
    • About Us
    • Leadership
    • Life at LT
    • Careers
  • People
  • Capabilities
    • Practice Groups
      • Business Restructuring & Insolvency
        • Business Restructuring & Insolvency Overview
        • Bankruptcy Chapters 7 and 13 Debtor
        • Bankruptcy Chapter 11 Debtor
        • Bankruptcy Chapter 11 Subchapter V Debtor
        • Business Wind Down and Liquidation
        • Court Appointed Trustees and Receivers
        • Creditors’ Rights
        • Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors in Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Proceedings
        • Prosecution and Defense of Avoidance Actions in Bankruptcy
        • Real Estate-Related Insolvency
      • Construction
      • Corporate
        • Corporate Overview
        • Asset Protection
        • Business Succession
        • Capital Markets
        • Commercial Contracts
        • Construction
        • Corporate Compliance & Ethics Program
        • Corporate Governance
        • Data Privacy & Cybersecurity
        • General Counsel
        • Government Relations
        • Investment Advisory
        • Lending
        • Mergers & Acquisitions
        • Nonprofits & Tax-Exempt Organizations
        • Secured Transactions
        • Securities
        • Software Development and Licensing
        • Start-Up Services
        • Tax
        • Women/Minority-Owned Businesses
      • Healthcare
        • Healthcare Overview
        • Healthcare Litigation
        • Healthcare Regulatory Compliance
        • Healthcare Corporate Transactions
        • Healthcare Government Investigations
      • Intellectual Property
        • Intellectual Property Overview
        • Copyright Protection
        • Litigation – Copyright
        • Litigation – Patent
        • Litigation – Trademark
        • Patent Preparation and Prosecution
        • Patent Validity, Infringement and Freedom to Operate Opinions
        • Trade Secret
        • Technology Agreements and Transactions
        • Trademark Clearance, Preparation, Prosecution and Maintenance
      • Labor & Employment
        • Labor & Employment Overview
        • Discrimination, Sexual Harassment and Employment Litigation
        • Employment Policies & Prevention
        • ERISA, Employee Benefits & Executive Compensation
        • Immigration
        • Public Sector Employment
        • Restrictive Covenants / Non-Competes
        • Traditional Labor Law
        • Wage and Hour
        • Workplace Investigations
        • Workplace Privacy
        • Workplace Safety/OSHA
      • Litigation
        • Litigation Overview
        • ADA Title III Defense Litigation
        • Alternative Dispute Resolution
        • Appellate
        • Commercial Litigation
        • Construction Litigation
        • Defamation: Libel, Slander, and Commercial Disparagement
        • E-Discovery
        • Election Law
        • Family Law and Matrimonial Law
        • Government & Internal Investigations
        • Insurance Coverage
        • Trusts & Estates Litigation
        • Product Liability Defense
        • Real Estate Litigation
        • Restrictive Covenants / Non-Competes
        • Shareholder / Equity Disputes
        • White Collar Defense
      • Real Estate
        • Real Estate Overview
        • Assessments and Appeals
        • Development
        • Environmental
        • Franchise Development & Leasing
        • Landlord/Tenant Law
        • Leasing
        • New York Co-Ops and Condominiums (Closing Capabilities)
        • Oil & Gas
        • Permitting and Zoning
        • Real Estate Litigation
        • Real Estate-Related Insolvency
        • Transactional Commercial
        • Transactional Residential
        • Leech Tishman Closings
      • Tax
      • Trusts & Estates
        • Trusts & Estates Overview
        • Asset Protection
        • Basic & Complex Estate Planning
        • Charitable Planning & Giving
        • Federal Estate, Gift, and Fiduciary Taxation and Compliance
        • Florida Homestead Exemption
        • Guardianships
        • Marital Agreements
        • Private Foundations
        • Probate and Orphans’ Court Practice
        • Special Needs Planning
        • State Estate, Inheritance, and Fiduciary Taxation and Compliance
        • Tax
        • Trust & Estate Administration
        • Trusts & Estates Litigation
        • Trust Creation, Modification, and Termination
    • Industries
      • Aviation & Aerospace
      • Beauty & Wellness
      • Cannabis
      • Data Privacy & Cybersecurity
      • Energy & Natural Resources
      • Entertainment & Sports
      • Healthcare
      • Life Sciences
    • International
      • International Overview
      • Asia Practice
      • Europe Practice
      • Latin America Practice
      • Middle East Practice
  • Insights
    • Client Alerts
    • Tariff Tracker
    • Firm News
    • Press
    • Events
    • Success Stories
    • Podcasts
    • Resources
    • Videos
  • Offices
    • How can we help you?

Insights

News Types

  • All
  • Client Alerts
  • Tariff Tracker
  • Firm News
  • Press
  • Events
  • Success Stories
  • Executive Orders
  • Resources
  • Videos
  • 30 Years, 30 Stories

Archives

DOJ Makes Workplace DEI an FCA Enforcement Risk

November 3, 2026

By: Lydia A. Pappas, Esq.

Summary:

  • Development: DOJ’s 2026 False Claims Act settlements with IBM, Deloitte, and Accenture highlight potential liability when DEI-related employment practices allegedly conflict with federal antidiscrimination certifications.
  • Why it matters: Federal contractors may face significant enforcement risks, but FCA liability still requires proof of a knowingly false claim or statement material to government payment. The settlements themselves do not establish liability.
  • Action point: Contractors should coordinate across HR, finance, and compliance teams to evaluate employment practices against federal certifications, address potential inconsistencies with counsel, and document the basis for future submissions.

The Department of Justice (“DOJ”) has opened a new front in False Claims Act (“FCA”) enforcement. Its May 19, 2025 Civil Rights Fraud Initiative directed use of the FCA against federal funding recipients that knowingly violate federal civil rights laws and falsely certify compliance. The resulting DEI investigations focus on whether contractors’ employment practices matched their antidiscrimination representations to the Government. In 2026, DOJ announced settlements with IBM, Deloitte, and Accenture totaling more than $63 million, challenging compensation and incentives, hiring and advancement, and access to professional opportunities.

These settlements warrant attention, but they are not judicial endorsements of DOJ’s theories. They resolve allegations without establishing that the challenged practices produced a knowingly false claim material to federal payment. For contractors, the question is not simply whether to rename a DEI program. It is whether actual practices support the representations they make when seeking federal money. Although these settlements involved major companies, they may provide DOJ with a model for pursuing similar allegations against smaller federal contractors, making these developments relevant to contractors of all sizes.

What DOJ’s Settlement Theories Reveal

1. IBM: Incentives and Scienter

On April 10, 2026, IBM agreed to pay $17 million. DOJ challenged a compensation modifier tied to demographic targets, “diverse interview slates,” business-unit goals, and development opportunities allegedly restricted by race or sex. The alleged problem was not the existence of a DEI policy, but how incentives and eligibility rules affected employment decisions.

For FCA liability, DOJ must connect IBM’s practices to an inaccurate federal representation and establish the company’s knowledge when it made that representation. In United States ex rel. Schutte v. SuperValu Inc., 598 U.S. 739 (2023), the Supreme Court focused on the defendant’s knowledge and subjective beliefs at the time of submission. A demographic target alone does not establish that personnel knew a certification was false. Contractors and their counsel should examine what decisionmakers understood, what concerns were raised, and how those concerns were resolved. DOJ credited IBM’s early disclosures and voluntary remediation. Companies should investigate concerns promptly and confirm that corrective action reaches the practices underlying later certifications.

2. Deloitte: Connecting the Practice to Federal Payment

On August 25, 2026, Deloitte agreed to pay $21.5 million. DOJ alleged that Deloitte certified compliance with Title VII obligations incorporated into its contracts and FAR 52.222-26 while considering race or sex in employment decisions. It also alleged that Deloitte allocated related costs to federal contracts and sought reimbursement. The American Alliance for Equal Rights brought the underlying qui tam action.

The cost allegation gives DOJ a more concrete payment theory than a general objection to company wide employment policies. However, a contractual obligation and charged costs do not, by themselves, establish materiality. The question is whether the alleged noncompliance would have mattered to the agency’s payment decision. Under Universal Health Services, Inc. v. United States ex rel. Escobar, 579 U.S. 176 (2016), an express condition of payment is relevant, but not conclusive. And continued payment despite actual knowledge is strong evidence against materiality, although not dispositive. This settlement does not decide that question. Companies should trace the affected personnel and cost pools to particular invoices and certifications, then examine agency disclosures, payment decisions, and renewals.

3. Accenture: What the Certification Actually Represented

Less than a month after Deloitte’s settlement, Accenture agreed to pay $25 million. DOJ alleged that workforce composition goals, monthly demographic reports, promotion procedures, and separate candidate pipelines affected hiring and advancement while the contractor certified that employment decisions would be made without regard to race or sex.

DOJ’s falsity argument rests on the alleged conflict between Accenture’s employment practices and its certifications. Evaluating that argument requires the certification’s precise language, scope, and timing. Monitoring demographics is not the same as using them to decide who receives an opportunity, and a disputed employment practice is not automatically a false claim. An allegedly false express certification presents a different question from an implied certification theory. If DOJ instead relies on omissions in claims describing goods or services, Escobar recognizes liability where material noncompliance makes those representations misleading. Contractors and their counsel should therefore review the actual representations alongside hiring, promotion, and program eligibility rules and not assume that a policy label answers the question.

Settlements Are Not a Judicial Test

DOJ is treating alleged antidiscrimination noncompliance as a potential false certification problem. The FCA permits liability for knowingly false claims or false statements material to those claims, with treble damages and civil penalties. It does not make every employment violation federal payment fraud.

These three settlements show the arguments DOJ is advancing, not how a court would resolve them on a contested record. DOJ would still have to establish the governing obligation, the false representation, the defendant’s knowledge, and materiality to a federal claim. A practice remote from the contracting entity, affected federal personnel, or charged costs may present a very different case. Neither the size of a settlement nor the Government’s enforcement priority supplies the missing proof.

Steps Contractors Can Take Now

The personnel who run employment programs need to coordinate with those who approve federal submissions. Contracting, finance, compliance, and human resources departments need to compare what the company does with what it certifies. That review should reach incentives, hiring and promotion decisions, and access to development programs, rather than stop at policy language. Where the review identifies a possible mismatch, companies should involve counsel before the next certification, determine whether corrective action is needed, and document the facts supporting any representation they ultimately make.

The IBM, Deloitte, and Accenture settlements give companies a reason to act, not a reason to assume every DEI practice creates FCA liability. Contractors should focus on identifying their actual obligations, examining the conduct DOJ would challenge, and determining how it relates to federal payment. A review grounded in actual practices, rather than program terminology, puts the company in a better position to support its certifications and respond to any DOJ inquiry.


This alert is part of an ongoing series tracking DOJ False Claims Act enforcement developments. View the previous alerts in the series below:

  • DOJ’s Revised False Claims Act Policies: New Defense Arguments for Contractors and Employers
  • DOJ’s Trade Fraud Crackdown Is Here: What Government Contractors Need to Know
  • DOJ Intensifies Focus on Small-Business Contracting Fraud: What Federal Contractors Need to Know

Leech Tishman has extensive experience advising clients on False Claims Act, qui tam, and government investigation matters. Our team is prepared to help clients assess compliance risks, respond to investigations, and address whistleblower claims and related enforcement issues. For assistance or additional information, please contact Lydia A. Pappas at lpappas@leechtishman.com, attorney in Leech Tishman’s Labor & Employment Practice Group.

Share on:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Careers
  • Insights
  • Payments
  • People
  • Contact
  • Chicago, IL
  • Los Angeles, CA
  • Miami/FLL, FL
  • New York, NY
  • Philadelphia, PA
  • Pittsburgh, PA
  • Sarasota, FL
  • State College, PA
  • Washington, D.C.

Sign up for our Client Alerts

Newsletter Signup
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Copyright © 2026 Leech Tishman: Legal Services All rights reserved.

  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Personnel Privacy Policy
We use cookies to provide and improve your experience on our website. By clicking Accept you are agreeing to the use of these cookies. However, you do have the option to select Deny but your digital experience may be negatively impacted.