Summary:
- Development: Plaintiffs increasingly target websites for alleged misrepresentations in cookie banners and privacy notices; courts vary in how they apply wiretapping and interception laws.
- Why it matters: Lawsuits can survive pleadings when sensitive or personal data is shared contrary to privacy statements; healthcare sites risk HIPAA complications if PHI is implicated.
- Action point: Perform tag/pixel audits, deploy consent management tools, and revise cookie banners and privacy policies to reflect actual data flows.
Simple online e-commerce and website hosting is now a minefield for class action privacy-related complaints.
Industry standard, household name content management and e-commerce platforms who provide business-enabling website development tools, turn-key e-commerce hosting and analytics/SEO services come at a risk if your website does not disclose your data-sharing practices adequately.
Unbeknownst to many business owners and website operators, more information, possibly containing personal data, maybe be flowing to third parties than they are even aware of.
As noted in previous client alerts covering CIPA, WESCA and other wiretap/interception focused class actions, Plaintiffs continue to devise novel pleading strategies to overcome prior dismissed complaints with an ever-increasing emphasis on alleged misrepresentations of cookie banners and privacy notices.
Both federal and state courts in the major wiretapping battleground states, such as Pennsylvania and California, continue to apply the law differently and arguably inconsistently. Some courts, thankfully dismissing generalized, presumptive wiretapping lawsuits that lack particularized injuries and specific claims of personal data sharing. However, other lawsuits that allege the capture of sensitive data and/or allege the capture of any personal data in contravention of assurances in cookie banners and privacy policies continue to make headway beyond the pleading phase, setting the stage for expensive litigation and, in some cases, large settlements.
However, businesses are not without tools to mitigate their risk of these lawsuits, no matter how novel or unsettled the underpinning law is on the matter. Most assuredly, if your business is served with a demand letter or lawsuit alleging the above violations, we have the knowledge and experience to defend your case. But we also have the tools and skills to help you significantly reduce the likelihood of these claims.
Implementing strategic changes to a company’s website infrastructure, cookie management, and consent management tools can mean the difference between business as usual, or a spate of wiretapping class action demand letters. We can help you do all of the above.
The issues listed above are particularly important for health-related businesses, covered entities, and business associates of those covered entities who are governed by HIPAA, because some courts have found that specific information searched by potential and established patients on websites that is shared with third party analytics providers could be sharing protected health information (“PHI”) in contravention of the HIPAA Privacy Rule.
Leech Tishman has extensive experience advising organizations on wiretapping allegations, cybersecurity concerns, and privacy-related matters. Our team is prepared to help clients assess their website vulnerability and how class action privacy-related complaints may affect their litigation risk, compliance programs, public data footprint, or response strategy. For assistance or additional information, please contact Jim Paulick, Partner in Leech Tishman’s Data Privacy & Cybersecurity and Litigation Practice Groups, at jpaulick@leechtishman.com or 424.738.4400.